Fish Crazy
Your one stop fish keeping site

More Stocking Advice....

Latest post 6-6-2008 9:40 by Olly_RPM. 9 replies.
  • 6-2-2008 16:02

    • Olly_RPM
    • Not Ranked
      Male
    • Joined on 1-22-2008
    • Derby City, UK
    • Posts 26

    More Stocking Advice....

     Hi All,

    I have a 35L Arcadia tropical setup with the following...

    6 x Cherry Barbs (2 Male, 4 Female)

    2 x Amano Shrimp

    2 x Male Endlers

    1 x Male Yellow Gourami

    I would like to add a bottom dwelling species and have considered adding 3 Panda or Pygmy Cory's, in addition to this I would like to up the number of endlers to a total of 4 males.  The tank is planted, has a coconut cave and contains a sand substrate.

    Would this be ok? Also I have read mixed reports regarding keeping a single male honey gourami, some say that they are best kept alone in a small tank and others disagree with this.

    Any thoughts and suggestions would be much appreciated. Yes

  • 6-2-2008 17:49 In reply to

    • DG
    • Top 75 Contributor
      Male
    • Joined on 7-10-2007
    • Henlow
    • Posts 556

    Re: More Stocking Advice....

     hi welcome to FC,cant really help,it wont be long before u get a reply.

    Rekord 70

  • 6-2-2008 21:38 In reply to

    Re: More Stocking Advice....

    Stocking levels should be about 12-14" in that tank in my estimation. Therefore you are really just about there I would have said (barbs 1.6" each, endlers 1.75" each, Gourami 2").

    Depends on your water parameters and water change regime - if they are OK and you change 25% a week religiously then you might be able to add some more. You might get away with 3 pygmy cory's?

    As to the Gourami, either one on it's own or groups of 5/6 or more.

    1xTrigon 190
    3 Clown Loaches,14 Cardinal Tetras,8 Rummynose Tetras,6 Cory Trileneatus,6 Hatchetfish,4 otocinclus,1 SAE,1 Bristlenose,, 10 amano Shrimp, 1 pair Apisto Agazzizi. 3 Blue Discus
    Anubius Barteri,Crinum thianum,Limnophilia sessiflora,Rotala rotundifolia, Echinodorus Blehri, Ech. Parviflorus,Ech. cordifolius, Ech. Tenellus, nymphaea lotus, Hygrophilia polysperma, Microsorum pteropus,Lilaeopsis brasiliensis

    1xRekord 60
    Blue Lobster, Flash plec
    2 Anubias Barteri, 1 Microsorum pteropus 12 litre tank - 3 Glass shrimp, 4 japonica shrimp 1 Anubias Barteri, Riccia, Eleocharis acicularis Coming Soon - Bluedave's 5' Bullnose Marine Divider (Watch this space!)

  • 6-2-2008 22:17 In reply to

    • Richy
    • Top 25 Contributor
    • Joined on 11-14-2004
    • Newcastle, England
    • Posts 4,622
    • POTM 3rd

    Re: More Stocking Advice....

    Your stocklist says "yellow gourami" but you mention "honey gourami" below. Are theses the same fish? Are you confused in some way? Yellows will grow too big for your tank where as Honey's won't grow anywhere the size the Yellows do.

    could you clarify please :)

    Panda's and Pygmy Cories, you need a pretty small grain gravel or sand  better to keep these, smaller aimed more at the pygmies.

    More info please Smile

  • 6-3-2008 15:21 In reply to

    • Olly_RPM
    • Not Ranked
      Male
    • Joined on 1-22-2008
    • Derby City, UK
    • Posts 26

    Re: More Stocking Advice....

     Blue Dave - I have always done 25% water changes on a weekly basis since I set the tank up in Jan,

    Richy - Its a honey gourami, the yellow kind, not the red kind.  I also have sand as a substrate, I have googled yellow gourami and all the results seem to display honey gouramis??

     

    So I could get away with 3 pygmy's? Are they smaller than Panda's? Is there any other differences?

     

    Olly.

  • 6-3-2008 17:18 In reply to

    Re: More Stocking Advice....

    My opinion is that you are close to being fully stocked. However every tank is different and the "stocking level calculators" are only a guide.

    Your water quality will tell you if you are overstocked and so testing to ensure nitrates are not going through the roof and ammonia and nitrites are zero is important.

    If it was me, i would go for it 'cause three pygmy cory's should be oK. Pygmy's are smaller than panda's.

    Hope that is a bit more clear!!!

    1xTrigon 190
    3 Clown Loaches,14 Cardinal Tetras,8 Rummynose Tetras,6 Cory Trileneatus,6 Hatchetfish,4 otocinclus,1 SAE,1 Bristlenose,, 10 amano Shrimp, 1 pair Apisto Agazzizi. 3 Blue Discus
    Anubius Barteri,Crinum thianum,Limnophilia sessiflora,Rotala rotundifolia, Echinodorus Blehri, Ech. Parviflorus,Ech. cordifolius, Ech. Tenellus, nymphaea lotus, Hygrophilia polysperma, Microsorum pteropus,Lilaeopsis brasiliensis

    1xRekord 60
    Blue Lobster, Flash plec
    2 Anubias Barteri, 1 Microsorum pteropus 12 litre tank - 3 Glass shrimp, 4 japonica shrimp 1 Anubias Barteri, Riccia, Eleocharis acicularis Coming Soon - Bluedave's 5' Bullnose Marine Divider (Watch this space!)

  • 6-3-2008 17:48 In reply to

    • Richy
    • Top 25 Contributor
    • Joined on 11-14-2004
    • Newcastle, England
    • Posts 4,622
    • POTM 3rd

    Re: More Stocking Advice....

    My fault, i mean't golden gourami but keep hearing people in the shop asking for "that yellow gourami" that i posted wrong lol

  • 6-3-2008 18:45 In reply to

    • Olly_RPM
    • Not Ranked
      Male
    • Joined on 1-22-2008
    • Derby City, UK
    • Posts 26

    Re: More Stocking Advice....

     Ok, thank you very much for your help so far.  I quite like the pygmy's, however my girlfriend really likes the pandas, as they are only slightly bigger than pygmy's could I get away with these?

     

    I think I will carry out tests during this week before purchasing at the weekend.

    Olly

  • 6-3-2008 21:05 In reply to

    Re: More Stocking Advice....

     panda's get to about 2", pygmies get to 1&1/4" so so two pandas are roughly the equivalent of three pygmies.

    You'd probs be alright with the panda's.

    definitely test your water before adding any mateYes

    1xTrigon 190
    3 Clown Loaches,14 Cardinal Tetras,8 Rummynose Tetras,6 Cory Trileneatus,6 Hatchetfish,4 otocinclus,1 SAE,1 Bristlenose,, 10 amano Shrimp, 1 pair Apisto Agazzizi. 3 Blue Discus
    Anubius Barteri,Crinum thianum,Limnophilia sessiflora,Rotala rotundifolia, Echinodorus Blehri, Ech. Parviflorus,Ech. cordifolius, Ech. Tenellus, nymphaea lotus, Hygrophilia polysperma, Microsorum pteropus,Lilaeopsis brasiliensis

    1xRekord 60
    Blue Lobster, Flash plec
    2 Anubias Barteri, 1 Microsorum pteropus 12 litre tank - 3 Glass shrimp, 4 japonica shrimp 1 Anubias Barteri, Riccia, Eleocharis acicularis Coming Soon - Bluedave's 5' Bullnose Marine Divider (Watch this space!)

  • 6-6-2008 9:40 In reply to

    • Olly_RPM
    • Not Ranked
      Male
    • Joined on 1-22-2008
    • Derby City, UK
    • Posts 26

    Re: More Stocking Advice....

     Ok.  Thanks ever so much for the advice.

     

    Olly Big Smile

Page 1 of 1 (10 items) | RSS
   Quick Reply:   (Click to Show ...)
Copyright © 2007 Fish Crazy. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by Community Server (Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems