Fish Crazy
Your one stop fish keeping site
Sign in
|
Join
|
Help
Home
Galleries
Forums
Profiles
Wikis
Calculators
Forums
»
Freshwater Aquatics
»
Inverts and Oddballs
»
Senegal Bichir and Figure of 8 Puffer's
Senegal Bichir and Figure of 8 Puffer's
rated by 0 users
This post has 26 Replies | 0 Followers
Posts
2,399
Reply
fry_keeper
Posted: 8-24-2007 18:46
rated by 0 users
Hi
I have just purchased a 4-foot tank with the following inhabitants; x3 Senegal Bichir, about 3-4" each and x6 Figure of 8 Puffer's, about 1" each.
I just wanted the tank and equipment really, i knew the tank had fish, but didnt know what fish, i was going to keep them or move them on. But since i have seen the fish i am in love with them. Perhaps people who have either of these species will know where i am coming from, they have so much personality it would seem.
Anyway, if i keep them in this tank, by main point of advice is, i am aware that even though Figure of 8 puffers are often found in freshwater as well as brackish water in the wild, they are considered a "brackish" fish (and some sites i have visited today insist they are FRESHWATER) the owner of this tank said he has had the Birchir's for about 6 months and then bought the Puffer's from an LFS about 3 months ago. The tank is running at normal freshwater levels and apparently the LFS said these Puffers were used to "nothing but fresh water?"
If i keep these fish together, which i want to, researching, they have similar dietary requirements (somewhat), what level of salinity shall i aim for? Can the Bichir put up with a low level brackish environment, say 1.003 or something? And will that be okay for the Puffer's? or shall i just stick to freshwater?
Also, do you think the Bichir's will have the Puffers for dinner at some point, as the Figure of 8's rarely get bigger than 2-3" ?
Thanks
hmmm, cant shift this name
Posts
2,438
Reply
stingrays4
replied on
8-24-2007 19:54
rated by 0 users
Hi FRY_LOVER O0
That is quite a combination ;D
I haven't kept figure of 8 puffers so cannot comment on them, but have kept bichirs O0
The bichirs will tolerate very hard water p/h8+ but i have not kept them in brackish water.
Good question-yes i reckon the bichirs will look on the puffers as food one day when they are big enough?but i have found that fish grown on together usually get on ok{usually ;D}
They do eat similar foods but as far as i know the puffers do require some snails in their diet to keep their teeth shortenend,the bichirs love any meaty food,but do not tend to take freeze dried foods? O0
Hi thought about time i updated this! Tank no 1 = 3 retic rays,1aro,2 ompuk cats,8 angels,1 syd greshoffi{19 years old},1 syd unkown,1 stripped dora,1 plec,1 silver dat,1 pim and a soribum lima! Tank no2 = 6 auralis barbs,2 needle gars,1 molly,1 dat microlepis,1 trye track eel and 8 bristlenoses! Tank no 3 = 2 goldfish{on holiday}1 flag tail thingy{over twenty years old},4 silver dats,1 pim and a plec!
Posts
2,399
Reply
fry_keeper
replied on
8-25-2007 10:53
rated by 0 users
Hi James
not looking good, i think the Figure of 8's need to go to LFS according to the advice i am receiving and if its a straight choice, as much i love the little buggers, i REALLY love the Bichirs tiphat
Wondering if i should just leave the x3 in there or a get a few more but its only a 48x12x15, they are stunning though (the Senegal Bichir)
One of my local LFS (Wildwoods) has South American Puffers in, i might get a couple, but they are £12 for 1" specimans OUCH!!!!!! :slap:
hmmm, cant shift this name
Posts
2,399
Reply
fry_keeper
replied on
8-25-2007 13:15
rated by 0 users
This is related to South American Puffer's which i am considering in place of the Figure of 8's
Initially i decided against SAP's due to dentistry, i didn't think it would be something i would be willing to do as part of fish keeping, but having read up on it, i am more confident.
Firstly, is this link a good method and a valid instruction?
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/s...erdentistry.htm
I am contemplating getting 3 or 4 SAP's, they will live with x3 Senegal Bichirs (about 4"
in a 48x12x15 (for the time being)
Questions
1. The SAP's in my LFS are only 1", with following correct diet, do you think it would probably be the standard 4-6 months before i need to do my first trimming?
2. If following procedure, is it rare for a SAP to die during the procedure or be permanently injured in some way?
3. I have used clove oil to euthanise fish, but never to perform dentistry obviously, is the use of clove oil the best way? How risky is this if you follow the procedure correctly?
4. From DAY 1 i want to feed my SAP (if i get them) appropriately, considering they would be only 1" can anyone please advise on a suitable REGIME, not just a list of foods, but a good ROUTINE?
Thanks
PS - i read that Malaysian Trumpet snails are NOT suitable food as the shell is too hard, is this true?
- Is it a "reasonable" risk to take with the SAP's and the Bichir? These Bichir have shared with x6 1" Figure of 8's for a while and not touched them (i didn't buy these fish, they came with the tank, thats a different thread). I guess as the Bichir's grow so will the SAP's.
- My main concern is the SAP's nipping the fins of the Bichir's. SAP's are known to be the most "peaceful" of Puffer's but i guess the risk still exists? How much of a risk do you think?
- I may well opt to not have any Puffer's at all, as i really do want to get into Birchirs and don't have any other tanks at moment to separate Bichir's and Puffer's
hmmm, cant shift this name
Posts
2,438
Reply
stingrays4
replied on
8-25-2007 20:41
rated by 0 users
Hi the link didn't work i'm afraid so i cannot comment on that one
With the puffer i had i never had to 'perform' dentisitry on it! i fed it snails on a regular basis{the ones with the long narrow shell-i forget what they are called}he simply bit them in half :o
but be carefull as mine once eat so many snails he almost eat himself to death{he laid on the bottom unable to move for 3 days :crazy2: but i'm sure he was smiling :2funny:!}The puffer in question was only 2 inches long!
as for fin nipping mine never once had ago at any other fish-but had a golden puffer and he was vindictive-but never actually 'bit' the other fish O0
as for feeding regime i fed mine the usal twice a day with 'normal'foods{frozen}and feed snails once or twice a week{about half a dozen at a time}
good luck and let us know if you decide to get the sap O0
Hi thought about time i updated this! Tank no 1 = 3 retic rays,1aro,2 ompuk cats,8 angels,1 syd greshoffi{19 years old},1 syd unkown,1 stripped dora,1 plec,1 silver dat,1 pim and a soribum lima! Tank no2 = 6 auralis barbs,2 needle gars,1 molly,1 dat microlepis,1 trye track eel and 8 bristlenoses! Tank no 3 = 2 goldfish{on holiday}1 flag tail thingy{over twenty years old},4 silver dats,1 pim and a plec!
Posts
2,399
Reply
fry_keeper
replied on
8-25-2007 20:59
rated by 0 users
You got me laughing here about the Puffer sitting on the floor for 3-days "smiling" after nearly gorging himself to death, sounds like me after a trip to the local curry house :coolsmiley:
hmmm, cant shift this name
Posts
2,675
Reply
ferox
replied on
8-26-2007 8:54
rated by 0 users
Hey Fry, I seem to recall a thread of your's about a year ago when you were trying to decide what to do with a new tank, and an African community was a possibility.
Now here's your chance. Keep the bichirs of course but dump the puffers (or put them elsewhere), replace them with african butterfly fish, congo tetras and a syno or two. Maybe some Xenomystus knifefish or a mormyrid (eg an elephant nose) too, but I'm not sure how well these would get on sharing the bottom of the tank with the bichirs.
Good luck with the bichirs anyway, they are terrific fish.
7
8 tanks (tropicals)
, and a pond.
Without understanding, knowledge is worthless
Posts
141
Reply
pam b
replied on
8-26-2007 13:09
rated by 0 users
Ah Birchirs,
such great fish, we owned a Palmas for several years, some days it was better than watching telly, we had a huge 4inch Sword in with him along with other stuff that i cant remember, he was a terror so we decided for him to take his chance with the birchir pmsl, and they actually got along, how weird is that. On the odd occasion we'd come home and find the Birchir had an orange sword poking out of his mouth, we'd rescue the sword and he'd swim off with a *FFS* look on his face.
No harm ever came to him i hasten to add. O0
Great fish, have fun,
We're gonna be setting up a 4ft (initially) and keeping Ornates, we lost our Birchir about 10 years back now, but once a Birchir owner you always will still think of them and return.
Cheers
Pam
Posts
2,399
Reply
fry_keeper
replied on
8-26-2007 17:35
rated by 0 users
[quote author=ferox link=topic=18945.msg244182#msg244182 date=1188118492]
Hey Fry, I seem to recall a thread of your's about a year ago when you were trying to decide what to do with a new tank, and an African community was a possibility.
Now here's your chance. Keep the bichirs of course but dump the puffers (or put them elsewhere), replace them with african butterfly fish, congo tetras and a syno or two. Maybe some Xenomystus knifefish or a mormyrid (eg an elephant nose) too, but I'm not sure how well these would get on sharing the bottom of the tank with the bichirs.
Good luck with the bichirs anyway, they are terrific fish.
Hello Brother!
Yeh, well the Puffers are gone and i now have x4 small Senegal Birchirs and x2 small Reed Fish (i know they will get long).
I just stumbled across your thread this morning when you got that Ornate, they are lovely but i need to stick to the smaller varieties. They are such nice fish to look at, i am so glad to have something other than Community or Cichlids now.
As for African Butterfly fish, i was tempted, but they dont seem to "do" much if you catch my drift, the ones at the LFS just sit in the same spot, dont move all day
How's your Ornate? how big is it and what you feeding it?
hmmm, cant shift this name
Posts
2,675
Reply
ferox
replied on
8-26-2007 19:13
rated by 0 users
Reed fish - excellent! I've never seen these, you have to post some pics!
Last time I saw my ornate (which is about 8-10 inches) was about a month ago sorry to say - I've been out of the country that long, but the OH (bless her) has been keeping up with the feeding and he seems to be quite happy with Doromin sticks. When I get home he's going to be treated to a few juicy earthworms and a lot of other invertebrates collected locally.
I was in Singapore a couple of weeks ago (hope to get back there before I go home) and a shop I found had ornates for a quid or two each - mine was twenty (or would have been but I got him for a few swaps).
Don't worry about the size of the tank, even the biggest bichirs that top out at 18" are ok in a 4 footer as they aren't very active swimmers, don't need the space.
Butterfly fish are a lot more interesting than you might gather by watching them in the lfs, and what else do you have that occupies the top one inch of the tank and virtually never ventures deeper? It's wasted space otherwise!
It would be a pity to leave the tank with just the bichirs and reed fish, there's loads of fish that would get along with them nicely and you have the potential there for a very interesting community.
7
8 tanks (tropicals)
, and a pond.
Without understanding, knowledge is worthless
Posts
2,399
Reply
fry_keeper
replied on
8-26-2007 20:08
rated by 0 users
Hello my Son!
Reed fish are wicked, my friend has x2 that are now about 8" and fatter than my two, his two hang around together all day long and i hoping mine will do the same, i also bought some plastic piping today for this set-up.
To be honest Ferox i was looking for x1 carnivorous 4-7" mid-level swimmer to complement the x4 Bichir and x2 Reed Fish, and in the end i made a bit of an impulse buy. I got x2 Jaguar Cichlids at about 3" and they are gorgeous, if they don't get on one will go in my American Cichlid 300 litre tank. Jags are very predatory and carnivorous so i thought they would go well, but i am well aware that this 48x12x15 will not hold all these fish for perhaps more than 12 months.
I thought Jags were a similar size to a Green Terror, but they are bigger, and apparently 12-14" is common, so i will have to see how it goes, but mate, i am sure you are aware, but google some pics of Jags, they are stunning, i am hoping my two will be okay with each other.
I know need to get the diet sorted, want to really give them 100% great feedings!!! I have no problem with over filtering a tank and doing loads of water changes.
I will take some pics in next few days mate......
by the way, i went to about 5 LFS today and the prices for 4-5" Ornates was £18.95 and for 6-7" Ornates it was £22.95 and for 9-10" Ornates it was £32.95 :police:
hmmm, cant shift this name
Posts
2,675
Reply
ferox
replied on
8-27-2007 4:40
rated by 0 users
A quick google on Jags has me convinced you'd probably be safer keeping crocodiles, but they really are gorgeous, I'm looking forward to hearing how you get on with them and seeing some photos. Just keep your fingers out of the water!
........and if they breed put me down for a few fry! ;D
Don't be tempted to overfeed, I did read somewhere that bichirs don't need daily feeding, every 2 or 3 days is plenty as they will gorge themselves on perhaps just one large food item and not move around much afterwards (Fry_Lover and curry springs to mind once more). They do seem to relish earthworms, and I'm tempted to try mine on small garden slugs. If he goes for those I might let him out in the garden some warm night, make him work for his living.
As for tankmates, my bichir has only a featherfin syno for company at the mo but if I can pick up cheap aros in Singapore and transport them safely home they will go in there. If not I will probably go for the african community thing.
7
8 tanks (tropicals)
, and a pond.
Without understanding, knowledge is worthless
Posts
2,399
Reply
fry_keeper
replied on
8-27-2007 14:47
rated by 0 users
Hi mate
i have been a bit naughty getting x2 Jags, they are about 3" at moment and hanging around together a lot, but they are simply stunning, i have not had a fish with that body shape before (the way mouth is position), yes they do have a fierce reputation, i will keep my eye out, i have upgraded My tank ALREADY from a 48x12x15 to a 48x12x18 just for a bit more space, i cant upgrade bigger as i don't have a stand big enough and i don't want a repeat of "Houston we have a catastrophe" :idiot2:
I know basically 48x12x18 may hold the Jags for quite a bit if they get on, if they don't i will move one and i am sure a 48x12x18 will be fine for one Jag for quite a while.
As for feeding, yes good point, i reckon it would be quite easy to feed the Jags x1 daily but only the Reed Fish and Bichir's every 2-3 days. I don't think any of the food will hit the bottom if i feed the Jags carefully every day.
I was browsing though Google and i cant find the link now, but one Jaguar fanatic was passionately arguing they are the 2nd most intelligent of all Tropical fish, cant remember what the most intelligent was :-\ maybe a guppy
Gordon, what was also fascinating was the behaviour of the Reed fish in the bucket i had them in for a hour or so, getting them used to the tank water, it is a 40 litre bucket (big bucket!) and i don't think oxygen was an issue, but sometimes the Reed Fish (both of them) would stick their heads out the water (about 1cm of their body length) and just sit there, like they were looking for something!!! It then become quite clear they were trying to "climb out" i could see one constantly trying to climb up the side of the bucket but he couldn't manage it!
I know about their rep for leaving tanks, so my glass panels that slide across top of the tank are very secure and in the small gap at the corner of the tank where my external filter feeds through, i have stuffed the remaining "space" that they "could" climb through with filter wool
hmmm, cant shift this name
Posts
2,438
Reply
stingrays4
replied on
8-27-2007 19:35
rated by 0 users
Hi Ferox is right about the feeding of the birchirs,but they will let you know if they are not getting enough as they will nick the jaguars food ;D
Birchirs are one of the most fearless fish i have ever kept >
:knuppel2:
mine fed on cockles,mussels,worms,lance fish,krill and live rivershrimps!
ps ornates in my lfs £20 for a four inch fish
Hi thought about time i updated this! Tank no 1 = 3 retic rays,1aro,2 ompuk cats,8 angels,1 syd greshoffi{19 years old},1 syd unkown,1 stripped dora,1 plec,1 silver dat,1 pim and a soribum lima! Tank no2 = 6 auralis barbs,2 needle gars,1 molly,1 dat microlepis,1 trye track eel and 8 bristlenoses! Tank no 3 = 2 goldfish{on holiday}1 flag tail thingy{over twenty years old},4 silver dats,1 pim and a plec!
Posts
2,675
Reply
ferox
replied on
8-27-2007 20:13
rated by 0 users
Yes Alex, my comment about letting the bichir out in the garden to eat slugs was only about 95% tongue in cheek - in the wild they will leave the water to feed. Quite a few fish will do this, including stinging catfish (
Heteropneustes
),
Clarias
. mudskippers and the common european eel.
I find this behaviour fascinating, what is more apparently unnatural than a fish out of water, but it can cause problems if you're trying to keep them in a tank! Many years ago I kept a
Heteropneustes
which once spent about 5 hours wandering around the carpet and lived to tell the tale.
Also I remember a story (true or not it's a great story) in PFK maybe 20 years ago about a large South American catfish (don't know which species) that escaped from a tank during the night and the owners woke up to find it on the carpet and one of their kittens missing. Brilliant tale.
James is spot on about the fearlessness of bichirs, they are completely unfazed whatever you do, but they do learn very fast. If the jaguar is the 2nd most intelligent fish maybe the bichir is first? Wouldn't surprise me, they must at least be in the top ten.
7
8 tanks (tropicals)
, and a pond.
Without understanding, knowledge is worthless
Previous
|
Next
Page 1 of 2 (27 items) 1
2
Next >
|
RSS
Copyright © 2007-2008 Fish Crazy. All Rights Reserved.